Skip to main content
San Jose Civic Gallery City Hall agenda intelligence

Matter CC 24-302

Digital Billboard Status Report

Economic Development Community & Economic Development Committee (CED) Agenda Ready Introduced 15 Feb 2024
6 Documents on file 17.1 MB · 6 extracted · 6 AI summaries
File
CC 24-302
Type
Reports to Committee
Status
Agenda Ready
Requester
Office of Economic Development
Introduced
15 Feb 2024
Last synced
12 Jun 2026 · 16:20

The papers

01 219 KB

Memorandum

219 KB Extracted AI Summary
file becc9543-a655-4240-8e23-708178218036.pdf sha 30a288e0b378 source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

This memorandum provides a status report on the efforts to implement large-format digital signage on City-owned property in San José. It outlines the background, analysis, and next steps regarding the placement of digital signage aimed at enhancing commercial vibrancy, removing blighted billboards, generating revenue, and facilitating emergency notifications. The report details the processes for select and alternative sites, including RFP solicitations, environmental reviews, and anticipated timelines for project completion.

Key points
  • The memorandum is addressed to the Community and Economic Development Committee.
  • It discusses the implementation of large-format digital signage on City-owned property.
  • The initiative aims to enhance commercial vibrancy, remove blighted billboards, and generate revenue.
  • The City Council approved a new policy in 2018 allowing various types of signage on City-owned land.
  • The implementation is divided into two processes: select sites and alternative sites.
  • The status report includes timelines for project-level environmental analysis and lease negotiations.
  • Recommendations for selected sites and alternative sites are expected to be brought to the City Council by December 2024.
Limitations
  • The text contains unresolved placeholders such as specific dates and details regarding the RFP processes.
  • Some sections are incomplete or lack specific details about the proposals received.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 11,471 chars
CED COMMITTEE: COUNCIL AGENDA: 2/26/24 10/24/22 FILE: CC 24-302 ITEM: (d)3 TO: COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE SUBJECT: SEE BELOW Approved SUBJECT: FROM: Chris Burton Nanci Klein DATE: February 16, 2024 Date 02/15/24 LARGE-FORMAT DIGITAL SIGNAGE ON CITY-OWNED PROPERTY STATUS REPORT RECOMMENDATION Accept the status report on efforts to advance the placement of large-format digital signage on City-owned property. OUTCOME Provide the Community and Economic Development Committee with a status report on the implementation of large-format digital signage on City-owned property. BACKGROUND The placement of large-format digital signage on City-owned property seeks to enhance the commercial vibrancy of downtown San José, remove blighted static billboards throughout the City, generate revenue opportunities for the City, and explore digital technologies that could allow real-time emergency notifications and City messaging to residents. From 2016 to 2018, the Department of Planning, Building, and Code Enforcement and the Office of Economic Development and Cultural Affairs completed analyses and multiple rounds of engagement and discussion with community stakeholders,...
02 524 KB

Presentation

524 KB Extracted AI Summary
file 6fab0912-891a-48fa-924b-3140f0cc0606.pdf sha 093245de4eba source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The source text indicates this attachment appears to be a draft document.

This document provides a status update on electronic large-format signage on city-owned property, detailing goals, background, work plan, and next steps related to the initiative. It outlines the objectives to enhance commercial vibrancy, generate revenue, and improve emergency notifications. The work plan includes two RFP processes for building-mounted and free-standing signage, with various milestones and timelines for environmental analysis and lease agreements.

Key points
  • Goals include enhancing commercial vibrancy, generating revenue, and allowing real-time emergency notifications.
  • Background includes community engagement and the approval of Council Policy 6-4 in September 2018.
  • Two separate RFP processes are outlined: one for building-mounted signage and another for free-standing signage.
  • Milestones include initial RFPs issued in 2019, with subsequent NOIAs and environmental processes planned through 2024.
Limitations
  • The document appears to be a draft as it includes placeholders and lacks finalized details.
  • Specific dates and outcomes of the RFP processes are not fully detailed.
  • Some sections contain unresolved placeholders affecting the completeness of the summary.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 2,620 chars
Electronic Large-Format Signage on City-Owned Property Status Update Community and Economic Development Committee Item d(3) February 26, 2024 Blage Zelalich, Deputy Director, Office of Economic Development and Cultural Affairs Robert Manford, Deputy Director, Department of Planning, Building and Code Enforcement Digital Signage on City-owned Property: Goals  Enhance the commercial vibrancy of Downtown  Generate revenue opportunities for the City  Explore digital technologies to allow real-time emergency notifications and messaging to residents Denver, Co  Remove blighted static billboards Perez Museum, 2Miami Fl Background  2016-2018: Staff analyses and engagement with community, tenants of City-owned properties, and billboard/sign companies  September 2018: Approval of new Council Policy 6-4, allowing billboards, programmable signs and signs displaying off-site commercial speech  17 sites, up to 22 signs  Direction to release RFPs for building-mounted signs in Downtown and free-standing freeway-facing signage on City-owned property 3 Work Plan  Work divided into two separate RFP processes 1) Select Sites process: Building-Mounted Signage • Initial RFP issued August...
03 82.1 KB

Memorandum from Torres, 2/26/2024

82.1 KB Extracted AI Summary
file 9776ac32-1326-41d3-ab81-529251ddfea6.pdf sha 1a46fa9da4de source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

This memorandum from Councilmember Torres provides a status update on the implementation of digital billboards in Downtown San José. It recommends accepting a staff report, directing the City Manager to proceed with signage on five city-owned sites, and allocating a portion of the revenue to a Community Advisory Group for local enhancements. The memorandum also emphasizes the need for timely action to avoid delays in revenue generation for community improvements.

Key points
  • The memorandum is addressed to the Community & Education Development Committee.
  • It recommends accepting a staff status report and directing the City Manager to proceed with digital signage on five city-owned sites.
  • The five sites include Market/San Pedro Street Garage, Second and San Carlos Street Parking Garage, Center for Performing Arts, McEnery Convention Center, and The Tech Interactive.
  • 20% of the annual revenue from the signage will be reinvested into Downtown San José through a Community Advisory Group.
  • The Community Advisory Group will provide grants to non-profits and community groups for enhancing vibrancy and promoting arts and culture.
  • The memorandum seeks to finalize the Select Sites by September 2024 and bring recommendations to the City Council on March 12, 2024.
  • The memorandum clarifies and reaffirms prior Council direction regarding the digital signage RFP awarded to Orange Barrel Media.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 3,556 chars
CED AGENDA: 2/26/24 ITEM: d(3) TO: COMMUNITY & EDUCATION DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE FROM: Councilmember Torres SUBJECT: DIGITAL BILLBOARD STATUS UPDATE DATE: February 26, 2024 Approved Date: 2/26/24 RECOMMENDATION 1. Accept the staff status report. 2. Direct the City Manager to: a. Proceed with Large Format Digital Signage on five (5) City-Owned Select Sites i. Market/San Pedro Street Garage ii. Second and San Carlos Street Parking Garage iii. Center for Performing Arts iv. McEnery Convention Center v. The Tech Interactive b. Allocate 20% of the annual revenue produced by the five (5) Building- Mounted Signage and by the Free-Standing Signage in District 3 to be reinvested back into Downtown San José through a community advisory group overseen by the District 3 Council office. The Community Advisory Group shall provide grants to non-profit organizations and community groups that seek to: i. Enhance commercial/residential vibrancy. ii. Activation and revitalization efforts in Downtown San José, and iii. Promote arts, culture, and placemaking opportunities in District 3 3. Return to the City Council with fully negotiated leases, completed environmental reviews, and final approvals of...
04 6.81 MB

Letters From the Public

6.81 MB Extracted AI Summary
file 0fdffdf5-dc4f-411a-9f33-340ab1af6e5e.pdf sha 52cdf3b88cf9 source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The document contains multiple letters from residents urging the San Jose City Council to oppose new digital billboard proposals. The letters express concerns about driver safety, light pollution, and the lack of public support for billboards, citing a city survey showing 90% opposition. The writers argue that digital billboards do not benefit local businesses and may harm the community's vibrancy. They request that their comments be included in the public record for upcoming committee meetings.

Key points
  • Residents urge the San Jose City Council to oppose new digital billboard proposals.
  • Concerns include driver safety, light pollution, and lack of public support.
  • A city survey indicated 90% opposition to billboards.
  • Writers argue that digital billboards do not benefit local businesses.
  • Comments are requested to be included in the public record for upcoming committee meetings.
Limitations
  • The text contains multiple letters with similar content, but specific details such as names and email addresses are not fully extracted.
  • Some sections of the text are truncated, leading to incomplete information.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 56,038 chars
| oppose Digital Billboards in San José Maria Hennessy MIS Thu 2/15/2024 1:52 PM To:Mahan, Matt <Matt.Mahan@sanjoseca.gov> Cc:district3@sanJose.gov <district3 @sanjose.gov>;CEDCommittee <CEDCommittee@sanjoseca.gov>; steering.committee@billboardsno.org <steering.committee@billboardsno.org> [External Email] You don't often get email from PO Learn why this is important Dear Mayor Mahan and San Jose City Council Members, | am writing to urge you to oppose any new billboard proposals in our community. My reasons are below: Billboards and the myth of urban vibrancy are all talking points of the billboard industry. There is no evidence electricity-hungry digital billboards on public buildings downtown would be good for the economy. It's more than likely just the opposite would happen. Billboards all over downtown will drive people away. Lobbyists and special interests are the ones asking for digital billboards. Council members have had many meetings with lobbyists from billboard companies in the last three months and not one meeting with anyone who thinks digital billboards are bad news. Is that because they are getting financial encouragement from these lobbyists? Driver distraction -...
05 8.34 MB

Letters from the Public

8.34 MB Extracted AI Summary
file 09ea0b7a-46ee-4ddb-a252-746703d00e20.pdf sha 44aa82bfcdb3 source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The document contains multiple letters from residents of San Jose expressing opposition to the proposal for new digital billboards in the city. Concerns raised include visual disturbance, environmental impact, driver safety, lack of public support, and potential legal issues. The letters urge the City Council to reject the billboard proposals and emphasize the overwhelming public opposition based on a city survey. The letters are intended for inclusion in the public record for a Community and Economic Development Committee meeting scheduled for February 26, 2024.

Key points
  • Residents oppose the addition of digital billboards in downtown San Jose.
  • Concerns include visual disturbance, environmental impact, and driver safety.
  • A city survey indicated 90% opposition to billboards among over 2000 respondents.
  • Letters emphasize that the public is not asking for billboards and that lobbyists are influencing decisions.
  • There are calls for the City Council to consider the long-term implications and potential legal issues related to billboards.
Limitations
  • The text contains multiple instances of unresolved placeholders and formatting issues.
  • Some letters are incomplete or truncated, affecting the clarity of the arguments presented.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 55,164 chars
| oppose digital billboards in San Jose Thu 2/22/2024 11:00 AM To:CEDCommittee <CEDCommittee@sanjoseca.gov> Cc:steering.committee@billboardsno.org <steering.committee@billboardsno.org> [External Email] [You don't often get email from christiaan.beekhuis@googlemail.com. Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldentification ] Dear CED committee, | have been a resident of downtown San Jose since 1989 and love it here. However, the proposal to add a large number of digital billboards is disturbing to me. This email is a request that this proposal be rejected. | feel that these billboards will be visually disturbing to the residents and visitors to downtown. In addition, they have a significant negative environmental impact related to their nighttime light pollution and large energy use. It is unclear to me why the City Council is proceeding when the public is overwhelmingly against this proposal. Please reject it. Respectfully, Christiaan Beekhuis Sent from my iPhone This message is from outside the City email system. Do not open links or attachments from untrusted sources....
06 1.19 MB

Letters from the Public

1.19 MB Extracted AI Summary
file 570c84d9-987e-4c5a-be02-b3fe112baedf.pdf sha e815c113880a source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The document contains correspondence regarding opposition to electronic billboards in San Jose. Multiple individuals express concerns about the negative impact of these billboards on the community, including light pollution, distraction for drivers, and adverse effects on wildlife. The correspondence includes messages from Paul Nyhof, who emphasizes the visual degradation and safety issues, and Shaunn Cartwright, who shares personal health challenges exacerbated by digital billboards. Bryan Reyes, a Legislative and Policy Analyst, acknowledges the concerns and commits to presenting them to the relevant authorities.

Key points
  • Paul Nyhof opposes electronic billboards, citing visual degradation and distraction for drivers.
  • Concerns about light pollution affecting wildlife are raised.
  • Shaunn Cartwright describes personal health issues worsened by digital billboards.
  • Bryan Reyes acknowledges the concerns and will present them to the Legislative Director and Councilmember.
Limitations
  • The document includes multiple email threads with some repeated content.
  • There are unresolved placeholders and formatting issues in the extracted text.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 5,713 chars
A OOO From: District3 Sent: Monday, February 26, 2024 12:53 PM To: Paul Nyhof; CEDCommittee Subject: Re: Deny Electronic Billboards Good afternoon, Councilmember Torres appreciate your time and thanks you for your insight and perspective on this issue. I will note your position down and present it to the Legislative Director and Councilmember next time an opportunity presents itself. For any other concerns regarding policy or district concerns please feel free to email me at bryan.reyes@sanjoseca.gov or this email district3 @sanjoseca.gov. Warm Regards, Bryan Reyes Legislative and Policy Analyst Office of Councilmember Omar Torres San José | District 3 E: bryan.reyes@sanjoseca.gov P: 408 535 4931 200 E Santa Clara St. - 18th Floor From: Pau! Nyc OMS Sent: Monday, February 26, 2024 9:11 AM To: CEDCommittee <CEDCommittee @sanjoseca.gov>; District3 <district3 @sanjoseca.gov> Subject: Deny Electronic Billboards | [External Email] Some people who received this message don't often get email from MMM. Learn why this is important Hello, lam very much opposed to the eyesore of electronic billboards in my community. Not only will it degrade the scene of the city, but they are distracting...