Skip to main content
San Jose Civic Gallery City Hall agenda intelligence

Matter ROGC 25-282

Ordinance Prohibiting Law Enforcement Officers from Concealing their Identities in the City of San José. (Ortiz, Kamei, Cohen, and Campos)

Public Safety Joint Meeting for the Rules and Open Government Committee and Committee of the Whole Agenda Ready Introduced 04 Sep 2025
6 Documents on file 21.4 MB · 6 extracted · 6 AI summaries
File
ROGC 25-282
Type
Rules Committee Reviews, Recommendations and Approvals Consent
Status
Agenda Ready
Requester
Unknown
Introduced
04 Sep 2025
Last synced
19 May 2026 · 04:10

The papers

01 196 KB

Memorandum from Ortiz, Kamei, Cohen, and Campos

196 KB Extracted AI Summary
file bdfeed4f-117f-4eb8-a4a2-8bf705f38dda.pdf sha 3ae0f4c6e0b2 source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The source text indicates this attachment appears to be a draft document.

The memorandum from Councilmembers Ortiz, Kamei, Cohen, and Campos addresses a proposed ordinance aimed at prohibiting law enforcement officers in San José from concealing their identities while interacting with the public. The ordinance includes provisions for visible identification, prohibits the use of masks or disguises with certain exceptions, and mandates reporting on federal immigration enforcement activities. The City Attorney's Office is directed to draft the ordinance based on a template from the California Immigrant Policy Center. The memorandum emphasizes the importance of transparency and accountability in law enforcement to maintain public trust.

Key points
  • Proposed ordinance prohibits law enforcement officers from wearing masks or disguises while interacting with the public.
  • Exceptions to the prohibition include medical masks and protective gear during emergencies.
  • All law enforcement officers must wear visible identification and provide their name and agency affiliation upon request.
  • The ordinance aims to enhance transparency and accountability in law enforcement.
  • The City Attorney's Office is tasked with drafting the ordinance within 60 days.
Limitations
  • The attachment contains unresolved placeholders such as the name of the city and specific sections of the municipal code.
  • The document appears to be a draft as indicated by the presence of placeholders and the lack of finalized details.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 16,067 chars
RULES COMMITTEE: ITEM: TO: RULES AND OPEN GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE 9/10/2025 C.2 FROM: Councilmember Ortiz Councilmember Kamei Councilmember Cohen Councilmember Campos SUBJECT: SEE BELOW DATE: September 4, 2025 Approved: Date: 9/4/2025 SUBJECT: ORDINANCE PROHIBITING LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS FROM CONCEALING THEIR IDENTITIES IN THE CITY OF SAN JOSÉ RECOMMENDATION Direct the City Attorney’s Office to return within 60 days with proposed language for a draft ordinance that would: 1. Prohibit Concealment of Identity o Prohibit all law enforcement officers, including federal agents operating within the City of San José, from wearing any mask or personal disguise while interacting with the public in the course of their duties within the city. o Appropriate, pre-approved exemptions would apply, including the use of gas masks, fire/smoke protection masks, or medical grade masks, when necessary, as well as exemptions for lawful undercover law enforcement operations and operations predefined by the Chief of Police. 2. Require Visible Identification o All law enforcement officers, including federal agents operating within the City of San José, must wear visible identification and clear agency...
02 364 KB

Letter from Assemblymember Ash Kalra

364 KB Extracted AI Summary
file ac9fba8a-cdd0-4510-b237-a44059b1d36a.pdf sha 91fb2e0c75d5 source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

Assemblymember Ash Kalra writes to Chair David Cohen and the Rules and Open Government Committee of San José, urging support for an ordinance that would require law enforcement officers to visibly identify themselves. Kalra emphasizes the importance of transparency in policing to enhance public trust and safety, referencing recent legislative support for similar measures.

Key points
  • Kalra advocates for an ordinance to prohibit law enforcement from concealing their identities.
  • He argues that transparency in law enforcement is essential for accountability and public trust.
  • The letter references recent support for legislation (SB 627 and SB 805) aimed at requiring law enforcement to identify themselves.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 1,612 chars
September 10, 2025 Chair David Cohen et al. Rules and Open Government Committee City of San José 200 E. Santa Clara Street San José, CA 95113 Subject: Support Ordinance Prohibiting Law Enforcement Officers from Concealing Their Identities in the City of San José Dear Chair Cohen and the Committee, It is long past time for the City of San José to restore one of the most basic and fundamental rights in this country: the right to know who has the authority to enforce arrests. Secret policing is characteristic of authoritarian regimes that use fear and distrust to control their citizens. In democratic societies, it has long been a standard that members of law enforcement are clearly identifiable so their actions can be held accountable and subject to legal and public scrutiny. When there is no transparency allowing the public to know who is acting on behalf of our government, it creates more opportunities for impersonators to exploit residents’ vulnerabilities and deepen public mistrust. Yesterday, the State Assembly voted in support of SB 627 (Wiener) and SB 805 (Pérez), legislation to require law enforcement to identify themselves clearly. These two legislative initiatives aim to...
03 12.3 MB

Letters from the Public (1 of 3)

12.3 MB Extracted AI Summary
file 07592010-e1d3-4212-ad59-d7982ec7894a.pdf sha 6c9ba3b56248 source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The source text indicates this attachment appears to be a draft document.

The document contains multiple letters from members of the public expressing support for a memo proposed by certain Councilmembers. This memo directs the City Attorney to draft an ordinance that would require law enforcement officers, including federal agents, to wear visible identification and prohibit them from concealing their identities while interacting with the public in San José. The letters emphasize the importance of transparency and accountability in law enforcement to build trust within the community, particularly in light of recent incidents involving ICE officers and impersonators. The writers urge the Rules Committee to move the memo forward to enhance community safety and protect civil rights.

Key points
  • Support for a memo proposed by Councilmembers Ortiz, Kamei, Cohen, and Campos.
  • The memo directs the City Attorney to draft an ordinance requiring law enforcement officers to wear visible identification.
  • The ordinance aims to prohibit officers from concealing their identities while interacting with the public.
  • Transparency and accountability are highlighted as essential for building trust between law enforcement and communities.
  • Recent incidents involving ICE officers and impersonators have raised concerns about public safety and confidence.
  • The letters call for the memo to be moved forward to ensure protection and respect for all residents.
Limitations
  • The text includes placeholders such as '{FirstName}' which indicate missing information.
  • The document appears to be a draft as it contains multiple instances of the same content from different individuals.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 101,039 chars
9/8/25, 4:02 PM Mail - Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas - Outlook oh Outlook Fw: Item C-2 Sept. 10th Rules Committee: Support for No Secret Police Memo From Agendadesk <Agendadesk@sanjoseca.gov> Date Mon 9/8/2025 3:34 PM To Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas <rulescommitteeagenda@sanjoseca.gov> From: City Clerk <city.clerk@sanjoseca.gov> Sent: Monday, September 8, 2025 3:33 PM To: Agendadesk <Agendadesk@sanjoseca.gov> Subject: FW: Item C-2 Sept. 10th Rules Committee: Support for No Secret Police Memo From: Aricka Arana O'Hara] Sent: Monday, September 8, 2025 2:14 PM To: City Clerk <city.clerk@sanjoseca.gov> Subject: Item C-2 Sept. 10th Rules Committee: Support for No Secret Police Memo [External Email. Do not open links or attachments from untrusted sources. Learn more] Clerk San Jose Councilmember, Dear Rules Committee Members, If you want to keep yourself, your family, your friends, your community and your constituents safe, please move this memo forward. YOU, MYSELF, and ALL OF US ARE IN DANGER AND AT RISK FOR PROSECUTION AND GREAT HARM BY OUR FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. I am writing to express my strong support for the memo proposed by Councilmembers Ortiz,...
04 1.67 MB

Letters from the Public (2 of 3)

1.67 MB Extracted AI Summary
file 3d912c75-d76b-4cbb-991f-d2ae9f70dede.pdf sha df220b4604cc source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The source text indicates this attachment appears to be a draft document.

The text contains a public testimony from an individual named Kylie B. expressing concerns about the actions of ICE and advocating for a local ordinance to prohibit law enforcement from using facial coverings or identity concealment. The testimony emphasizes the fear experienced by brown-skinned individuals regarding potential targeting by ICE and calls for clear penalties for violations of the proposed ordinance.

Key points
  • Kylie B. identifies as Kanaka Maoli (Native Hawaiian) and expresses disagreement with U.S. immigration policies.
  • The testimony highlights concerns about ICE's treatment of non-white individuals and the use of anonymity by law enforcement.
  • Kylie B. requests the Rules Committee to approve a No Secret Police Memo.
  • The proposed ordinance should include penalties for violations to ensure enforcement.
Limitations
  • The text appears to be a draft as it is part of a larger correspondence and lacks formal structure.
  • There are unresolved placeholders and missing information regarding the context of the testimony.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 2,038 chars
9/9/25, 11:12 AM Mail - Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas - Outlook green light, ICE is effectively operating as the American Gestapo for non-white people in this country. When we couple ICE's deep, flagrant racism with masking/concealment policies, we have a "law enforcement" agency that is made up of people who outwardly hate brown-skinned folks and get to hide any and all of its actions--like verbally attacking and kidnapping and torturing brown-skinned people--behind a shield of anonymity. I am Kanaka Maoli (Native Hawaiian), so I will never truly understand or agree with the US' absurd immigration policies--nobody can be "illegal" on stolen and illegally occupied land. But I am also a brown-skinned person who lives in San Jose, and although I may be a US citizen, I know I'm at a real risk of being targeted by ICE, like my friends and colleagues and neighbors who are similarly not white. Our skin color and the language(s) we speak and the type of jobs we work and our immigration statuses ARE NOT CRIMES. We should not be in fear of masked agents hunting us down and kidnapping us like we are criminals. I therefore implore the Rules Committee to approve this No Secret...
05 2.93 MB

Letters from the Public (3 of 3)

2.93 MB Extracted AI Summary
file bbf475cc-e5e6-4e07-9454-5cfe4757cade.pdf sha a2895b6f0fd3 source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The document contains a message from Demerris Brooks Immel, located in San Jose, California. It appears to be part of a correspondence related to the Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas.

Key points
  • Sender: Demerris Brooks Immel
  • Location: San Jose, California
  • Related to: Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas
Limitations
  • The message is incomplete and lacks specific details regarding the content or purpose of the correspondence.
  • There are unresolved placeholders such as {FirstName} that affect the completeness of the summary.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 449 chars
9/10/25, 8:22 AM Mail - Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas - Outlook Sincerely {FirstName} Demerris Brooks Immel 995 San Jose, California 95125 This message is from outside the City email system. Do not open links or attachments from untrusted sources. https://outlook.office365.com/mail/rulescommitteeagenda@sanjoseca.gov/inbox/id/AAQkADhhYzk3NTk1LTBmZDAtNDc4Yi1hN2Q0LTZjNmZjNTk5MT… 2/2
06 3.95 MB

Documents Received Post Meeting

3.95 MB Extracted AI Summary
file bae4a51c-18b9-4cde-89bb-63a05337561e.pdf sha 117acdc908ae source unavailable

Official source link unavailable. The file was imported, but the current source metadata does not include a public document URL.

Generated summary AI-assisted

The source text indicates this attachment appears to be a draft document.

The document contains correspondence regarding a memo proposed by certain Councilmembers aimed at enhancing transparency and accountability in law enforcement interactions with the public in San José. The memo suggests that law enforcement officers, including federal agents, should be required to wear visible identification and prohibits the use of masks or disguises. The correspondence expresses strong support for this initiative, emphasizing the importance of trust between law enforcement and the community.

Key points
  • The memo is proposed by Councilmembers Ortiz, Kamei, Cohen, and Campos.
  • It directs the City Attorney to draft an ordinance prohibiting law enforcement officers from concealing their identities.
  • The ordinance aims to enhance transparency and accountability in law enforcement.
  • It addresses concerns regarding incidents of ICE officers and impersonation of federal agents.
  • The proposed changes are intended to strengthen community safety and protect civil rights.
Limitations
  • The document appears to be a draft as it references ongoing discussions and proposals.
  • There are unresolved placeholders in the email headers and signatures.

Generated for convenience from extracted text using AI. Review the official source document before relying on this summary.

Extracted text preview · 2,724 chars
9/11/25, 10:06 AM Mail - Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas - Outlook Thank you for your consideration. This message is from outside the City email system. Do not open links or attachments from untrusted sources. https://outlook.office365.com/mail/rulescommitteeagenda@sanjoseca.gov/inbox/id/AAQkADhhYzk3NTk1LTBmZDAtNDc4Yi1hN2Q0LTZjNmZjNTk5MT… 2/2 9/12/25, 2:49 PM Mail - Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas - Outlook Outlook FW: Item C-2 Sept. 10th Rules Committee: Support for No Secret Police Memo From City Clerk <city.clerk@sanjoseca.gov> Date Fri 9/12/2025 2:32 PM To Rules and Open Government Committee Agendas <rulescommitteeagenda@sanjoseca.gov> From: Soomin Song Sent: Friday, September 12, 2025 12:28 PM To: City Clerk <city.clerk@sanjoseca.gov> Subject: Item C-2 Sept. 10th Rules Committee: Support for No Secret Police Memo [External Email. Do not open links or attachments from untrusted sources. Learn more] Clerk San Jose Councilmember, Dear Rules Committee Members, I am writing to express my strong support for the memo proposed by Councilmembers Ortiz, Kamei, Cohen, and Campos, which directs the City Attorney to draft an ordinance prohibiting law enforcement...